10 Best Organic Fertilizers for Herbs to Grow a Thriving Garden

I’ve tested numerous organic fertilizers for herbs, and my top recommendations include Dr. Earth Home Grown with TruBiotic technology for containers and raised beds, TPS Nutrients liquid formula for indoor herbs, and Organic Plant Magic water-soluble blend with 55+ trace minerals for versatile applications. Miracle-Gro Performance Organics provides instant nutrition, while Espoma Organic Grow! offers gentle 2-2-2 balanced feeding. Each fertilizer serves specific needs, from quick-release nutrition to long-term soil health enhancement, ensuring your culinary herbs thrive with proper selection and application techniques that I’ll explore further below.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more. Last update on 12th September 2025 / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API.

Notable Insights

• Choose fertilizers with balanced NPK ratios like True Organic (5-4-5) to provide essential macronutrients without burning delicate herb plants.
• Select quick-acting liquid fertilizers like TPS Nutrients or Espoma for faster results, or slow-release granular options for sustained feeding.
• Prioritize OMRI-certified products like Miracle-Gro Performance Organics and Burpee to ensure safe consumption of harvested herbs.
• Consider beneficial microbes and mycorrhizae in fertilizers like Dr. Earth to improve soil health and enhance nutrient uptake.
• Match fertilizer coverage to garden size and choose application methods that suit your setup, whether containers or garden beds.

Dr. Earth Home Grown Organic Tomato, Vegetable & Herb Fertilizer – 4lb

If you’re seeking a thorough organic solution that nourishes herbs while building long-term soil health, Dr. Earth Home Grown Organic Fertilizer delivers exceptional results through its TruBiotic technology. This 4-pound formula combines five beneficial soil microbes with eighteen strains of mycorrhizae, creating a living ecosystem that enhances nutrient availability and drought tolerance. You’ll appreciate how it releases nutrients quickly while continuing to feed your herbs for several months, eliminating frequent reapplication needs. The organic blend works particularly well with basil, rosemary, and thyme, promoting larger, more abundant harvests. With coverage for 60 square feet, it’s perfect for containers, raised beds, and traditional garden plots.

Best For: Organic gardeners who want a comprehensive fertilizer solution that builds long-term soil health while providing both quick and sustained nutrient release for herbs, vegetables, and tomatoes in containers, raised beds, or traditional garden plots.

Pros:

• Contains TruBiotic technology with 5 beneficial soil microbes and 18 strains of mycorrhizae that enhance nutrient availability and drought tolerance
• Provides both immediate and long-term feeding (continues for several months), reducing the need for frequent reapplication
• Made with 100% organic and natural ingredients without synthetic chemicals, GMO chicken manure, or sewage sludge

Cons:

• May attract pets to treated areas, which could be problematic for some gardeners
• Higher price point compared to conventional synthetic fertilizers
• Limited to 60 square feet of coverage, requiring multiple bags for larger garden areas

TPS NUTRIENTS Herb Plant Food for Edible Herbs and Veggies (8 oz)

TPS NUTRIENTS Herb Plant Food delivers targeted nutrition for gardeners who cultivate edible herbs, leafy greens, and vegetables in indoor environments. This 8-ounce liquid fertilizer provides quick-acting nutrients that many users notice within days of application. You’ll appreciate the odorless formula, which makes indoor feeding more pleasant than traditional fertilizers with strong smells.

Results vary depending on your growing conditions, particularly lighting levels during winter months. Users report dramatic improvements in basil, parsley, oregano, and sage, with visible growth appearing within one week of treatment. However, some gardeners experience mixed results with herbs like rosemary and catnip in low-light situations.

Best For: Indoor gardeners growing edible herbs, leafy greens, and vegetables who want a quick-acting, odorless liquid fertilizer that’s safe for food plants.

Pros:

• Fast results with visible improvements in plant health and growth within 3-7 days of application
• Odorless formula makes it pleasant to use in indoor environments unlike traditional fertilizers
• Easy to use liquid format that’s economical and safe for edible plants

Cons:

• Effectiveness varies significantly depending on plant type, with mixed results for herbs like rosemary and catnip
• Performance is heavily dependent on adequate lighting conditions, showing reduced effectiveness in low-light winter environments
• Some users report no noticeable improvements even after several weeks of consistent use

Organic Plant Magic Fast-Acting Water Soluble Plant Food (1/2 lb Bag)

Organic Plant Magic Fast-Acting Water Soluble Plant Food delivers extensive nutrition that makes it ideal for gardeners who want versatile, quick-dissolving fertilizer for their herb gardens and beyond. This concentrated formula contains essential nutrients plus 55+ trace minerals, amino acids, humic acids, kelp, and beneficial GroBiotics including mycorrhizae. You’ll appreciate how easily it dissolves when mixed with water, and one half-pound bag treats up to 1,000 square feet or makes 32+ gallons of nutrient solution. The fertilizer encourages intense herb production with vibrant flavor while promoting healthy living soil through continuous feeding.

Best For: Gardeners seeking a versatile, organic fertilizer that works effectively for herbs, vegetables, flowers, and houseplants while promoting healthy soil with beneficial microorganisms.

Pros:

• Contains comprehensive nutrition with 55+ trace minerals, amino acids, humic acids, kelp, and beneficial GroBiotics including mycorrhizae
• Highly concentrated formula where one half-pound bag treats up to 1,000 square feet or makes 32+ gallons of solution
• Easy to use with multiple application methods – can be added directly to soil, transplant roots, or mixed with regular watering

Cons:

• Notable compost-like smell when mixing that some users may find unpleasant
• Can be messy if spilled and requires cleanup
• Label lacks clear organic certification information and pricing may be considered high by some users

True Organic All Purpose Plant Food – Organic Fertilizer (4lb Bag)

Herb enthusiasts seeking an extensive, naturally-derived fertilizer will find True Organic All Purpose Plant Food delivers exceptional nourishment for their culinary gardens. This organic formula provides balanced nutrition with 5% nitrogen, 4% phosphate, and 5% potash, ensuring your herbs receive essential macronutrients for robust growth. The fertilizer’s innovative blend includes seabird guano, shrimp and crab shell meal, soybean meal, and fish bone meal, creating a sustainable foundation that enriches soil health while feeding your plants. You’ll appreciate the slow-release nitrogen component, which provides steady nutrition throughout the growing season without burning delicate herb foliage. Apply this versatile fertilizer monthly to both container and in-ground herbs for consistently thriving culinary gardens.

Best For: Herb enthusiasts and gardeners who want an organic, sustainable fertilizer that provides balanced nutrition for culinary gardens without risking burn damage to delicate plants.

Pros:

• Contains slow-release nitrogen (3.75% of 5% total) that provides steady nutrition throughout the growing season without burning sensitive herb foliage
• Features an innovative blend of sustainable ingredients including seabird guano, shrimp and crab shell meal, soybean meal, and fish bone meal that enriches soil health
• Versatile application for both container and in-ground plants with simple monthly feeding schedule during growing season

Cons:

• Requires monthly applications throughout the growing season, which may be more frequent than some synthetic alternatives
• The 4lb bag only covers 87 square feet, which may not be sufficient for larger garden operations
• Organic formulation may take longer to show visible results compared to fast-acting synthetic fertilizers

Miracle-Gro Performance Organics Edibles Plant Nutrition (1 lb.)

Gardeners seeking a reliable, OMRI-listed fertilizer that delivers immediate nutrition will find Miracle-Gro Performance Organics Edibles Plant Nutrition perfectly suited for their herb gardens. This organic plant food feeds your herbs instantly, whether they’re growing in containers or planted directly in garden beds. You’ll appreciate its convenient application methods, as it works seamlessly with the Miracle-Gro Performance Organics Garden Feeder or a simple watering can for versatile feeding options. The 1-pound package covers up to 265 square feet when used with the garden feeder, making it economical for extensive herb cultivation. Apply this nutrient-rich formula every seven days to maintain consistent growth and promote abundant harvests of flavorful herbs throughout the growing season.

Best For: Gardeners who want an organic, OMRI-listed fertilizer that provides instant nutrition for tomatoes, vegetables, herbs, and fruits in both containers and garden beds.

Pros:

• OMRI-listed organic formula that feeds plants instantly for immediate results
• Versatile application methods using either the Miracle-Gro Garden Feeder or a watering can
• Excellent coverage of up to 265 square feet per 1-pound package when used with the garden feeder

Cons:

• Requires weekly applications every 7 days, which may be more frequent than some gardeners prefer
• Limited to edible plants only, not suitable for ornamental flowers or landscaping plants
• May require purchasing the separate Miracle-Gro Performance Organics Garden Feeder for optimal coverage

Burpee Natural Purpose Granular Organic Plant Food (4 lb)

When you’re seeking a versatile, long-lasting solution for nourishing your herb garden, Burpee Natural Purpose Granular Organic Plant Food delivers exceptional results through its all-inclusive nutrient blend. This OMRI-certified organic fertilizer provides immediate feeding while continuously nourishing your herbs for up to three months, ensuring sustained growth and enhanced flavor development. The granular formula contains essential major nutrients, calcium, minor nutrients, and beneficial microbes that work together to strengthen plant health and increase productivity. You’ll appreciate its versatility since it works effectively for herbs, vegetables, flowers, and container plants both indoors and outdoors. Backed by Burpee’s trusted legacy since 1876, this easy-to-apply fertilizer releases nutrients quickly for fast-acting results.

Best For: Gardeners seeking a versatile, long-lasting organic fertilizer for herbs, vegetables, flowers, and container plants that provides both immediate and sustained nutrition for up to three months.

Pros:

• OMRI-certified organic formula with beneficial microbes that feeds plants immediately and continues nourishing for up to 3 months
• Versatile application for indoor and outdoor use across vegetables, herbs, flowers, trees, shrubs, and containers
• Backed by Burpee’s trusted 145+ year legacy with easy-to-apply granules that deliver fast-acting results

Cons:

• 4-pound package size may be insufficient for large garden areas requiring frequent applications
• Granular format may not be ideal for liquid fertilizer systems or hydroponic setups
• No specific NPK ratio mentioned, making it difficult to compare nutrient content with other fertilizers

FoxFarm Big Bloom Plant Food Liquid Fertilizer Concentrate (Pint)

FoxFarm Big Bloom Plant Food delivers exceptional results for gardeners who prioritize natural, chemical-free nutrition while seeking to maximize the flavor and aromatic qualities of their herb gardens. This liquid fertilizer concentrate features a micro-brewed formula containing earthworm castings, bat guano, and other organic ingredients that enhance root development without synthetic chemicals. You’ll notice stronger flavors in your herbs, increased essential oil production, and more intense fragrances when you apply this versatile fertilizer regularly. The 0-0.5-0.7 NPK ratio makes it perfect for flowering and fruiting herbs, whether you’re growing them indoors or outdoors in containers. Simply mix the concentrate with water in your watering can for easy application.

Best For: Gardeners who want to enhance the flavor, fragrance, and essential oil production of their herbs, fruits, and vegetables using organic, chemical-free nutrition for both indoor and outdoor plants.

Pros:

• Contains natural organic ingredients like earthworm castings and bat guano without harmful synthetic chemicals
• Enhances flavor intensity, root development, and increases essential oil production in herbs and plants
• Easy to apply by simply mixing the concentrate with water and versatile for both indoor and outdoor use

Cons:

• Low NPK ratio (0-0.5-0.7) may not provide sufficient primary nutrients for heavy-feeding plants
• Requires regular application and mixing with water rather than being ready-to-use
• Pint size container may not last long for gardeners with extensive herb gardens or multiple plants

Espoma Organic Grow! Liquid Concentrate Plant Food (16oz)

This liquid concentrate fertilizer serves as a reliable solution for herb enthusiasts who need consistent, gentle nutrition for their culinary gardens. Espoma’s 2-2-2 formula contains natural proteins, kelp extracts, and humic acids that provide balanced nutrition without overwhelming delicate herb plants. You’ll appreciate its organic certification and USA-made quality, which guarantees safe application on herbs you’ll eventually harvest for cooking. The concentrate requires dilution every 2-4 weeks during growing season, making it economical for maintaining multiple herb varieties. While the initial smell during mixing can be quite strong, users consistently report excellent results within days, particularly for flowering herbs that benefit from gentle, sustained nutrition.

Best For: Herb gardeners and organic growers who want gentle, balanced nutrition for culinary plants they plan to harvest and consume.

Pros:

• Organic certification ensures safe use on edible plants with natural ingredients like kelp extracts and humic acids
• Economical concentrate formula that dilutes for multiple applications every 2-4 weeks during growing season
• Proven effectiveness with 4.6/5 star rating and visible results within days, particularly for flowering and fruiting plants

Cons:

• Strong, unpleasant odor during mixing that users describe as “funky” or like an “outhouse”
• Lower nutrient concentration (2-2-2) may not be sufficient for heavy-feeding plants or severely depleted soil
• Requires regular dilution and application every 2-4 weeks, which may be inconvenient for some gardeners

All-in-One Complete Organic Plant Food for Indoor and Vegetable Gardens

Plant enthusiasts who want convenient, mess-free feeding for their indoor herbs and vegetable gardens will find this all-in-one complete organic plant food particularly appealing. The single-serving packets eliminate measuring hassles while delivering both fast and slow nutrient release, ensuring your herbs receive sustained nourishment. You’ll notice improved root development, reduced transplant shock, and enhanced leaf color as beneficial microorganisms work to support soil health. Don’t worry if you observe white film appearing on your soil’s surface—this indicates healthy microbial activity that promotes nutrient cycling and plant health. Simply scratch it into the soil or cover with fresh potting mix to address any aesthetic concerns.

Best For: Plant enthusiasts who want convenient, mess-free feeding for their indoor herbs and vegetable gardens with organic, sustainable nutrition that supports long-term soil health.

Pros:

• Single-serving packets eliminate measuring and mess while providing both fast and slow nutrient release
• Contains beneficial microorganisms that promote soil vitality, root development, and reduced transplant shock
• Non-toxic, organic, and eco-friendly formula with a clean, pleasant earthy scent unlike traditional fertilizers

Cons:

• White mildew-like film may appear on soil surface, requiring additional steps to address aesthetic concerns
• Single-use packets may generate more packaging waste compared to bulk fertilizers
• Higher cost per application compared to traditional fertilizer options due to convenient packaging format

True Organic Multipurpose Plant Food – All-Natural Fertilizer for Plants

Gardeners seeking a reliable, eco-friendly solution for their herb gardens will find True Organic Multipurpose Plant Food delivers consistent results through its carefully balanced nutrient formula. This granular fertilizer contains 5% nitrogen, 4% phosphate, and 5% potash, providing essential nutrients your herbs need for vigorous growth. The slow-release nitrogen component guarantees steady feeding over time, while the blend of poultry manure, soybean meal, and fish bone meal creates a sustainable foundation for healthy soil development. You’ll appreciate the monthly application schedule during growing season, making it perfect for container herbs and small garden spaces up to 22 square feet.

Best For: Small-scale gardeners and container gardening enthusiasts who want an eco-friendly, slow-release fertilizer that’s easy to apply monthly and covers compact growing spaces up to 22 square feet.

Pros:

• Balanced nutrient formula with slow-release nitrogen ensures steady, long-term feeding without risk of burning plants
• Made from sustainable, all-natural ingredients including poultry manure, soybean meal, and fish bone meal for environmentally conscious gardening
• Simple monthly application schedule with excellent customer satisfaction (4.6/5 stars from 374 reviews) and proven effectiveness across various plant types

Cons:

• Limited coverage area of only 22 square feet makes it impractical and expensive for larger gardens or lawns
• Trial and error may be required for optimal results with specific plants like acid-loving varieties, as user experiences vary
• Higher cost per square foot compared to conventional fertilizers due to premium organic ingredients and smaller package size

Factors to Consider When Choosing Organic Fertilizer for Herbs

When I’m selecting organic fertilizers for my herb garden, I consider several key factors that directly impact plant health, application efficiency, and overall growing success. The nutrient release speed determines how quickly my herbs will respond, while my preferred application method affects convenience and coverage across different garden sizes. I also evaluate organic certification standards and plant safety considerations to guarantee I’m providing the safest, most effective nutrition for both my herbs and family.

Nutrient Release Speed

Understanding nutrient release speed becomes essential because it directly impacts how effectively your herbs receive the nourishment they need throughout their growing season. I recommend fast-acting organic fertilizers when your herbs show immediate deficiency signs, such as yellowing leaves or stunted growth, since these formulations deliver nutrients within days. For sustained feeding, I prefer slow-release options that provide consistent nutrition over weeks or months, reducing the risk of nutrient leaching while maintaining steady plant health.

The release rate depends on soil microbial activity, moisture levels, and temperature, which influence how quickly nutrients become available to your plants. I match fertilizer speed to my herbs’ specific needs: fast-acting for seedlings requiring rapid establishment, slow-release for mature plants during extended growing periods.

Application Method Preferences

Beyond timing your nutrient delivery, the method you choose for applying organic fertilizer greatly impacts both convenience and effectiveness in your herb garden. I recommend considering liquid concentrates for rapid nutrient uptake, especially when your herbs need quick recovery from stress or deficiencies. These water-soluble options deliver nutrients directly to root systems, making them ideal for immediate feeding. Granular fertilizers, however, provide sustained nutrition through slow-release mechanisms that support consistent growth over extended periods. For indoor herb gardening, I suggest selecting low-odor formulations that won’t overwhelm confined spaces with unpleasant scents. Single-dose packets eliminate measuring guesswork while reducing mess, particularly beneficial for beginners. Consider coverage area requirements too, as some fertilizers treat small containers while others nourish extensive garden beds effectively.

Coverage Area Requirements

Three key measurements determine whether an organic fertilizer will efficiently serve your herb garden’s coverage requirements without creating waste or nutrient gaps. I recommend calculating your garden’s total square footage first, then comparing it against fertilizer coverage specifications, which typically range from 60 to 1,000 square feet per package. You’ll find that fertilizers covering larger areas, like those treating up to 265 square feet, often provide better value for extensive herb gardens compared to smaller-coverage options. I suggest matching the fertilizer’s coverage area precisely to your garden size, ensuring even nutrient distribution throughout your growing space. Many quality fertilizers include detailed application rates per square foot, helping you calculate exact usage requirements and make cost-effective choices that align with your garden’s layout and plant density.

Organic Certification Standards

When selecting organic fertilizers for your herb garden, certification standards serve as your most reliable guide for guaranteeing product quality and environmental safety. I recommend looking for USDA organic certification, which guarantees products contain no synthetic substances, GMOs, or harmful chemicals that could compromise your herbs’ natural integrity. The OMRI label provides additional assurance, indicating rigorous testing and verification processes have confirmed the fertilizer meets strict organic standards. These certifications guarantee your fertilizer derives from natural sources like compost, guano, or mineral deposits, supporting both soil health and environmental sustainability. By choosing certified organic fertilizers, you’re investing in products that undergo thorough ingredient sourcing reviews and production method evaluations, giving you confidence in their quality and effectiveness.

Plant Safety Considerations

Choosing certified organic fertilizers provides the foundation for safety, but understanding how these products interact with your herb plants requires careful attention to several key factors. I recommend examining the nutrient release profile carefully, as quick-release formulations can cause nutrient burn if you apply them incorrectly, potentially damaging delicate herb foliage. The NPK ratios should match your herbs’ specific needs without overwhelming their root systems, particularly for tender varieties like basil and cilantro. I always check for beneficial microbes and natural ingredients that support soil health while ensuring the herbs remain safe for consumption. Additionally, consider any residual odors or residues that might attract unwanted pests to your garden space.

On a final note

I’ve shared eight exceptional organic fertilizers that’ll transform your herb garden into a productive, healthy ecosystem. Whether you choose Dr. Earth’s specialized blend, TPS Nutrients’ targeted formula, or Espoma’s liquid concentrate, you’re investing in sustainable gardening practices. Remember to take into account your herbs’ specific nutritional needs, soil conditions, and application preferences when selecting fertilizer. With these quality organic options, you’ll cultivate flavorful, nutrient-dense herbs while supporting beneficial soil microorganisms and environmental health.