10 Best Soils for Growing Herbs Indoors, According to Gardening Experts

I’ve tested numerous potting mixes for indoor herbs, and the best options include Burpee Premium Organic Potting Soil, Professional Indoor Herb Plant Soil, and Back to the Roots 100% Organic Mix. These blends provide excellent drainage through perlite, maintain proper pH levels between 6.0-7.0, and offer organic nutrients that enhance flavor. Look for OMRI-certified mixes with coconut coir for moisture retention and worm castings for healthy root development. Below, I’ll share my complete recommendations and selection criteria.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more. Last update on 12th September 2025 / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API.

Notable Insights

• Choose well-draining soil blends with perlite or coco coir to prevent root rot and promote healthy aeration.
• Select OMRI-listed organic potting mixes for superior herb flavor and growth without harmful synthetic chemicals.
• Maintain soil pH between 6.0-7.0 using testing kits and amendments like lime or sulfur as needed.
• Look for moisture-retaining ingredients like coconut coir and peat moss to reduce watering frequency in containers.
• Match soil drainage properties to container size, using fast-draining mixes for small pots with frequent feeding.

Burpee Premium Organic Potting Soil Mix (9 Quarts)

If you’re seeking an organic foundation that supports healthy herb growth from seed to harvest, Burpee Premium Organic Potting Soil Mix delivers the essential nutrients and structure your indoor garden needs. This OMRI-listed blend combines all-natural ingredients with coconut coir, creating an ideal environment for basil, oregano, thyme, and other culinary favorites. The mix includes slow-release plant food that feeds your herbs for up to three months, eliminating guesswork about fertilizing schedules. Coconut coir enhances moisture retention, ensuring your potted herbs maintain consistent hydration between waterings, which prevents stress and promotes vigorous growth in containers.

Best For: Home gardeners who want an organic, all-natural potting mix for growing herbs, vegetables, and flowers in containers or raised beds with consistent nutrient feeding and moisture retention.

Pros:

• OMRI-listed organic formula with slow-release plant food that feeds plants for up to 3 months
• Contains coconut coir for excellent moisture retention, reducing watering frequency and plant stress
• Suitable for both indoor and outdoor container gardening with versatile application for herbs, vegetables, and flowers

Cons:

• Limited 9-quart size may not be sufficient for larger gardening projects or multiple containers
• Higher cost compared to conventional non-organic potting mixes
• Slow-release fertilizer timing may not align with specific plant feeding requirements for all varieties

Professional Indoor Herb Plant Soil (2.2 Quarts, Made in USA)

Dedicated indoor gardeners who want professional-grade results for their herb gardens will find this specially formulated soil blend delivers exceptional performance in container environments. The 2.2-quart bag contains a precise mixture of peat moss, coco coir, perlite, and dolomite that creates ideal growing conditions for basil, thyme, rosemary, oregano, mint, parsley, and sage. This composition maximizes fertilizer absorption while promoting excellent aeration, ensuring your herbs receive essential nutrients efficiently. The blend’s moisture management system promotes proper drainage while retaining adequate water levels, helping prevent over-watering issues that commonly affect indoor plants. You’ll appreciate the resealable packaging and satisfaction guarantee.

Best For: Dedicated indoor gardeners who want professional-grade soil specifically formulated for growing herbs like basil, thyme, rosemary, oregano, mint, parsley, and sage in container environments.

Pros:

• Specially formulated blend of peat moss, coco coir, perlite, and dolomite maximizes fertilizer absorption and promotes excellent aeration for optimal herb growth
• Advanced moisture management system provides proper drainage while retaining adequate water levels to prevent over-watering issues
• Comes with satisfaction guarantee, resealable packaging for convenience, and access to plant care resources through the Leaves and Soul app

Cons:

• Small 2.2-quart size may not be sufficient for larger herb gardens or multiple plantings
• Higher cost per quart compared to generic potting soils due to specialized formulation
• Limited to herb plants and may not be suitable for other types of indoor plants or vegetables

Back to the Roots 100% Organic Potting Mix (6 Quart)

Environmentally conscious gardeners who prioritize sustainable growing practices will find Back to the Roots 100% Organic Potting Mix an exceptional choice for cultivating thriving indoor herb gardens. This premium, peat-free blend uses upcycled plant matter and wood fines, creating a lighter carbon footprint while delivering exceptional growing results. You’ll appreciate the thoughtful formulation that includes yucca extract for superior moisture control and dolomitic limestone for ideal pH balance. The 6-quart size provides ample soil for multiple herb containers, supporting everything from basil to rosemary with consistent, reliable nutrition. You’re also supporting education through their #GROWONEGIVEONE initiative, which donates classroom growing kits.

Best For: Environmentally conscious gardeners who want a sustainable, organic potting mix for growing herbs, vegetables, fruits, and flowers indoors or in containers.

Pros:

• 100% organic and peat-free formula made from upcycled materials reduces environmental impact
• Contains yucca extract and dolomitic limestone for optimal moisture control and pH balance
• Backed by 100% satisfaction guarantee with replacement or refund policy

Cons:

• 6-quart size may be insufficient for larger gardening projects or multiple plantings
• Premium organic formulation likely comes at a higher price point than conventional potting mixes
• Made from upcycled materials may have less consistent texture compared to traditional peat-based mixes

Organic Potting Soil Mix for Indoor & Outdoor Small Containers (1 qt)

This organic potting soil mix becomes the perfect foundation when you’re working with limited space and smaller containers for your indoor herb garden. The all-natural blend combines peat moss, perlite, coconut coir, and worm castings to create an ideal growing environment that encourages healthy development and vigorous new growth in your herbs. You’ll appreciate how the naturally-occurring perlite improves water drainage and breathability, expanding when exposed to heat to enhance overall soil performance for your plants. This versatile mix works exceptionally well for starting new herb seedlings or transplanting established plants into larger containers as they mature.

Best For: Indoor gardeners and herb enthusiasts working with small containers who want an organic, well-draining soil mix that promotes healthy plant growth in limited spaces.

Pros:

• All-natural organic blend of peat moss, perlite, coconut coir, and worm castings provides excellent nutrition and aeration
• Superior drainage and breathability from naturally-occurring perlite prevents waterlogging and root rot
• Versatile formula works for both starting seedlings and transplanting established plants

Cons:

• Small 1-quart size limits use to very small containers and may require frequent repurchasing for larger projects
• May dry out faster than regular potting soil due to enhanced drainage properties
• Higher cost per volume compared to conventional potting mixes due to organic ingredients

Miracle-Gro Organic Indoor Potting Mix (8 qt.)

Organic gardeners who prioritize sustainability and plant health will find Miracle-Gro’s Organic Indoor Potting Mix perfectly suited for their herb-growing needs. This OMRI-listed blend combines responsibly sourced sphagnum peat moss from certified producers, coir, and quick-start natural fertilizer to create ideal growing conditions. You’ll appreciate the watering protection technology that prevents both over and under watering, maintaining consistent moisture levels that herbs require. Whether you’re starting basil seeds or transplanting established oregano plants, this mix provides reliable nutrition and drainage. One 8-quart bag conveniently fills two 8-inch containers, making it perfect for creating your indoor herb garden.

Best For: Organic gardeners who want to grow herbs and houseplants indoors with a sustainable, OMRI-listed potting mix that provides watering protection and natural fertilization.

Pros:

• OMRI-listed organic formula made with responsibly sourced materials from certified producers
• Built-in watering protection technology prevents over and under watering for optimal plant health
• Includes quick-start natural fertilizer and provides excellent coverage (one bag fills two 8-inch containers)

Cons:

• Limited to 8-quart size which may not be sufficient for larger indoor gardening projects
• Contains peat moss which some gardeners prefer to avoid for environmental reasons
• May be more expensive than conventional potting mixes due to organic certification

Miracle-Gro Organic Outdoor Potting Mix (16 qt.)

Indoor herb gardeners who want convenient, nutrient-rich soil will find Miracle-Gro Organic Outdoor Potting Mix delivers exceptional value with its built-in fertilization system. This 16-quart blend contains quick-release natural fertilizer that nourishes your herbs for up to two months, reducing the frequency of supplemental feeding. The mix works perfectly for container-grown herbs like basil, oregano, and thyme, providing consistent nutrition as they establish and grow. You’ll appreciate the responsibly sourced peat from certified producers, which guarantees quality drainage and moisture retention. One bag fills a 12-inch container completely, making portion planning straightforward for your indoor herb garden setup.

Best For: Outdoor container gardeners growing flowers, vegetables, herbs, annuals, and perennials who want organic potting mix with built-in fertilization that lasts up to 2 months.

Pros:

• Contains quick-release natural fertilizer that nourishes plants for up to 2 months, reducing the need for frequent feeding
• Made with responsibly sourced peat from certified producers ensuring quality and sustainability
• Suitable for a wide variety of outdoor container plants including flowers, vegetables, herbs, annuals, and perennials

Cons:

• Specifically designed for outdoor use, not recommended for indoor plants
• Limited coverage with one 16 qt. bag only filling one 12-inch container
• Contains peat which some gardeners prefer to avoid due to environmental concerns despite being responsibly sourced

SuperMoss Agromin Organic Potting Mix (4 Quart)

When you’re seeking a premium organic growing medium that delivers consistent results, SuperMoss Agromin Organic Potting Mix stands out as an exceptional choice for indoor herb cultivation. This OMRI-listed organic blend combines compost, triple-ground redwood, perlite, and washed sand to create an ideal growing environment for your herbs. The sustainable formula, crafted from recycled materials, provides excellent drainage while retaining moisture, ensuring your basil, cilantro, and other herbs receive balanced nutrition. You’ll appreciate this ready-to-use mix‘s versatility, as it works beautifully for vegetables, flowers, and houseplants beyond herbs, making it a valuable addition to any indoor gardener’s toolkit.

Best For: Indoor gardeners and herb enthusiasts who want an organic, ready-to-use potting mix that provides excellent drainage and balanced nutrition for vegetables, flowers, herbs, and houseplants.

Pros:

• OMRI-listed organic certification ensures safe growing medium for edible plants
• Well-balanced blend of compost, triple-ground redwood, perlite, and washed sand provides optimal drainage and moisture retention
• Made from sustainable and recycled materials, making it an environmentally responsible choice

Cons:

• 4-quart size may be insufficient for larger gardening projects or multiple plantings
• Contains redwood which may make the mix more acidic, potentially requiring pH adjustment for certain plants
• Higher cost compared to conventional non-organic potting mixes

Miracle-Gro Houseplant Potting Mix (4 qt.)

Miracle-Gro’s Houseplant Potting Mix delivers exceptional value for gardeners who want reliable, gnat-resistant soil that’s specifically formulated for indoor herb cultivation. This 4-quart blend combines three essential components—perlite, sphagnum, and peat moss—creating ideal drainage and moisture retention for healthy herb development. You’ll appreciate the reduced gnat problems, which often plague indoor gardens and damage delicate herb seedlings. The Mulch & Soil Council certification guarantees you’re getting quality ingredients that meet industry standards for consistent performance. Each bag conveniently fills an 8-inch container, perfect for growing basil, oregano, or thyme on windowsills and countertops.

Best For: Indoor gardeners who want a reliable, gnat-resistant potting mix specifically designed for houseplants like Pothos, Spider Plants, Monstera, Philodendron, and English Ivy.

Pros:

• Gnat-resistant formula reduces common indoor gardening pest problems
• Contains optimal blend of perlite, sphagnum, and peat moss for proper drainage and moisture retention
• Certified by the Mulch & Soil Council ensuring quality and industry standards

Cons:

• Requires additional plant food after 30 days for optimal results
• Limited to 4-quart size which only fills one 8-inch container
• May not be suitable for plants that require specialized soil conditions

Indoor Herb Planters Soil for Kitchen Herbs (1 Quart Bag)

Gardeners who prioritize convenience and rapid results will find this specially blended soil mixture an excellent foundation for their culinary herb projects. This all-natural composition combines peat, perlite, lime, and worm castings to create an ideal growing environment that encourages healthy development and accelerated growth rates. The formula’s specialized blend guarantees your herbs establish strong root systems quickly, making it particularly effective for beginners seeking reliable success with their indoor gardens. You’ll appreciate how this soil mixture works exceptionally well in small windowsill pots, where space constraints often challenge traditional gardening approaches and limit container options for urban herb cultivation.

Best For: Beginner gardeners and urban dwellers who want to grow fresh kitchen herbs indoors with quick, reliable results in small windowsill containers.

Pros:

• All-natural composition with premium ingredients like worm castings and perlite promotes healthy root development and fast growth
• Specially formulated for herb cultivation, ensuring optimal growing conditions and higher success rates for culinary plants
• Perfectly sized for small indoor pots and windowsill gardens where space is limited

Cons:

• Small 1-quart bag size may require frequent repurchasing for multiple plants or larger containers
• Higher cost per volume compared to general-purpose potting soils due to specialized formulation
• Limited to herb cultivation and may not be suitable for other types of indoor plants

Miracle-Gro Organic Outdoor Potting Mix (25 qt.)

This OMRI-listed organic potting mix delivers the perfect foundation for herb enthusiasts who prioritize natural growing methods, while its quick-release fertilizer provides steady nutrition for up to two months. You’ll appreciate that this 25-quart bag contains responsibly sourced peat from certified producers, ensuring quality ingredients for your herb containers. The generous size covers three 10-inch planters, making it ideal for establishing multiple herb varieties like basil, oregano, and thyme in outdoor spaces. When planting, you’ll want to fill containers partially, position your loosened root balls carefully, then cover completely with the mix before watering thoroughly for peak establishment.

Best For: Herb enthusiasts and organic gardeners who want a natural, OMRI-listed potting mix with built-in fertilizer for outdoor container growing of flowers, vegetables, herbs, annuals, and perennials.

Pros:

• Contains quick-release natural fertilizer that feeds plants for up to 2 months, reducing the need for frequent fertilizing
• Made with responsibly sourced peat from certified producers and is OMRI-listed for organic use
• Large 25-quart bag provides good value and coverage, filling approximately three 10-inch containers

Cons:

• Limited to outdoor use only, not suitable for indoor container gardening
• Peat-based formula may raise sustainability concerns for environmentally conscious gardeners
• Coverage may vary significantly depending on root ball sizes, making quantity planning difficult

Factors to Consider When Choosing Soil for Growing Herbs Indoors

When I’m selecting soil for my indoor herb garden, I consider five essential factors that directly impact plant health and harvest quality. The drainage and aeration properties, organic versus synthetic ingredients, moisture retention capabilities, pH balance requirements, and container size compatibility all work together to create ideal growing conditions. I’ve learned that understanding these interconnected elements helps me choose the right potting mix for specific herbs, whether I’m growing basil in small containers or rosemary in larger pots.

Drainage and Aeration Properties

Although many gardeners focus primarily on nutrients, proper drainage and aeration form the foundation of successful indoor herb cultivation. I’ve learned that well-draining soil prevents waterlogging, which causes devastating root rot and fungal diseases that can destroy your entire herb garden. When you choose soil that includes perlite or coco coir, you’re enhancing aeration considerably, allowing roots to access the oxygen they desperately need for healthy growth. This proper drainage maintains ideal moisture levels by letting excess water escape while retaining enough during dry periods. I recommend selecting soil with organic matter like worm castings or peat moss, which creates the perfect balance between moisture retention and aeration, ultimately fostering robust plant health and improved nutrient absorption.

Organic Vs Synthetic Ingredients

While nutrients and drainage matter greatly, the choice between organic and synthetic soil ingredients affects both your herbs’ health and their ultimate culinary quality. I recommend organic potting mixes containing natural ingredients like peat moss, coconut coir, and worm castings, which promote robust growth without synthetic chemicals. These natural components excel at retaining moisture and nutrients, creating healthier root systems that support vigorous herb development. Synthetic soils often rely on chemical fertilizers that can create nutrient imbalances and introduce harmful residues into your plants. When you’re growing herbs for cooking, organic ingredients enhance flavor and overall quality markedly. Look for OMRI-listed organic potting mixes, which meet strict organic standards, ensuring your culinary herbs remain pure and flavorful for kitchen use.

Moisture Retention Capabilities

Three essential factors determine your soil’s moisture retention capabilities, and getting this balance right means healthier herbs with less guesswork about watering schedules. First, I recommend incorporating sustainable materials like coconut coir, which appreciably enhances your soil’s ability to hold water while preventing both over-watering and dehydration that can damage delicate herb roots. Second, adding perlite creates the ideal drainage-to-retention ratio, allowing your plants to absorb water efficiently without becoming waterlogged. Finally, blending peat moss with nutrient-rich worm castings provides that balanced moisture environment your herbs crave for ideal growth. This combination becomes especially vital in small containers where limited soil volume makes proper moisture management the difference between thriving herbs and struggling plants.

Ph Balance Requirements

Because most herbs perform best within a narrow pH range of 6.0 to 7.0, understanding your soil’s acidity level becomes essential for successful indoor gardening. I recommend testing your soil’s pH using inexpensive testing kits, which provide accurate readings that guide your soil preparation decisions. When your soil falls within this slightly acidic to neutral range, nutrients become readily available to your herbs, promoting robust growth and enhanced flavor development.

If you discover your soil is too acidic, you can raise the pH by adding lime, while sulfur effectively lowers overly alkaline soil. I’ve found that regular monitoring prevents the nutrient deficiencies that occur when pH levels drift too far from ideal ranges. Maintaining proper pH balance directly impacts your herbs’ health, ensuring they develop the vibrant flavors you’re cultivating them for.

Container Size Compatibility

The right soil choice depends considerably on your container size, which determines how your herbs will access nutrients, water, and oxygen throughout their growing cycle. I recommend smaller containers of 1-2 quarts for starting seedlings or compact herbs like thyme, while larger 6-16 quart containers work better for established basil or mixed plantings. In smaller pots, moisture builds up quickly, so you’ll need soil that drains exceptionally well while maintaining adequate aeration around delicate root systems. I’ve found that specialized herb blends in 1-2 quart packages perfectly match compact indoor setups, preventing waste while supporting healthy growth. Since smaller containers require more frequent feeding, I suggest choosing soil with slow-release nutrients that’ll sustain your herbs over time.

On a final note

Now that you’ve discovered these top-quality soil options, you’re ready to create a thriving indoor herb garden. Each potting mix offers unique benefits, from Burpee’s organic richness to specialized herb formulations. Remember to take into account drainage, nutrients, and container size when making your selection. With the right soil foundation, you’ll enjoy fresh basil, rosemary, and thyme year-round, transforming your kitchen into a productive growing space.